Justin du Coeur (jducoeur) wrote,
Justin du Coeur

I think it's getting to be time to shoot C++ in the head...

This article on Lambda the Ultimate was the first I'd heard of the new C++ concept of "Concepts". Basically, C++ is starting to recognize that its version of generic programming, while powerful, is kind of brittle, and it's remarkably easy to get remarkably confused by the bugs that arise from it.

If you read through the above-linked article, though, it kind of hurts. They're introducing a whole new idea (rather complex idea at that) that is rather parallel to interfaces, but limited to a rather precise purpose. It offends me in rather the same way that Single-Use Kitchen Gadgets offend Alton Brown. You can get nice clean, predictable compile-time behaviour from your templates, by adding new ideas of Concepts and Concept Maps that make it all twice as complex.

Bjarne Stroustrup, the god of C++, has a decent article on why the current model is over-complex, and seems to have a better handle on reality. But really, the whole thing leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I mean, yes -- I recognized long ago that C++'s days were pretty numbered. But this feels like such a hack onto the side of the language, and the rationalizations feel so tortured, that it just drives home that the language is obsolete. They're trying to shoehorn in what amounts to Scala's Trait system, but treat it as a special case so that they don't have to deal with the broader ramifications of the idea. Whereas the same functionality in Scala is far cleaner and better-integrated into the language -- it just recognizes that, once you truly go down that road, you wind up with a very different language...
Tags: programming

  • The Silk Road Trial

    Having finally finished reading through this, I commend Ars Technica's coverage of the trial of the Dread Pirate Roberts over the past few weeks.…

  • The higher the pedestal, the likelier somebody will fall off

    So we have a man who has been respected and admired for decades; who is highly charismatic and strongly opinionated, and who has spent many years…

  • Smock

    I just have to say, every time I hear the phrase, " Sophisticated underwear bomb" on the news, it gets funnier...

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded