Justin du Coeur (jducoeur) wrote,
Justin du Coeur

Why Bitcoin is forking -- a case study in group dynamics

[Not really a tech post]

Came across this interesting article about Bitcoin this morning. The summary is that the Bitcoin project is splitting in two, because of an irreconcilable difference of opinion between the five people who control the project.

The details are technical, but it mostly stands as a good case study in why process matters: as described, the project has come to loggerheads because it depends fatally on the squishy notion of consensus -- worse, it sounds like it depends on unanimity. That's usually a bad idea for any project of serious scope, and this is a fine illustration as to why.

As it happens, the project *does* have a way of coping: fork the code and let the users choose, which is a common approach in the open-source world. But that's not an option in most situations...

  • the dogs

    We of course ate out throughout our stay in Edinburgh, mostly at local restaurants in the residential part of town. (Part of the motivation for…

  • Vacation: Motel 1

    [And now for the promised assorted notes from me] Our hotel in Edinburgh was something I haven't encountered in the US: inexpensive without feeling…

  • Oh, right -- we took this vacation

    Kate and I spent the beginning of the month in the UK, visiting first her northern relatives and then our friends pir and Miko. Here are Kate's…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded